And Then the Earth Shook and Trembled: Rattle, the BPO and Bruckner’s Ninth

27/02/2012

A. Bruckner: Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra, Sir Simon Rattle (conductor), Carnegie Hall, New York 24.2.2012 (SSM)

Bruckner –Symphony No. 9 in D Minor with the US premiere of the final movement. Performance version by Samale-Phillips-Cohrs-Mazzuca (1983 – 2011)

Carnegie Hall has been both blessed and cursed. The main concert hall, officially the Isaac Stern Auditorium/Ronald O. Perelman Stage, is considered to be ideal acoustically. Unfortunately, it sometimes suffers from being right next to a subway station. There were moments in this concert when one thought a train had made a wrong turn and ended up in the hall: the floor shook as far back as our seats in row W, but the vibrations came from the stage, not the subway.

The performance revealed an image of Bruckner far from that of the country bumpkin who had childish ambitions of being the next “B” in the pantheon of Bach, Beethoven and Brahms. He is still seen by some as the idiot savant who built pointless crescendo after crescendo only to have nothing at the crescendi’s peaks: a musical Sisyphus never quite reaching his goal. As to the caveats about his old-fashioned style of composing, which looked backward and not forward, one only had to hear Sir Simon Rattle and the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra to ask if there has ever been a Scherzo more tragic and less Scherzo-like, or an Adagio more poignant and at the same time more apocalyptic. If Bruckner’s life-long quest was be the next Beethoven and to write a ninth symphony on the level of Beethoven’s Ninth, in this monumental work he was not far from his mentor’s own masterpiece.

Only rarely is there an interpretation that makes us want to reexamine a composer’s works in a particular genre or even his entire output. In our time one thinks of Glen Gould and his icononoclastic reinterpretation of J. S. Bach’s keyboard music, Leonard Bernstein’s revival of Mahler or Sir Thomas Beecham’s “rediscovery” of Delius. Here, from  the ab initio (or should we say de profundis?) tremolos played pianissimo to the final three pizzicati of the third movement Adagio, the audience was held spellbound. Any orchestra under any conductor can play loudly, but few can inject such raw terror into each sonic burst that it becomes almost too painful to hear.

Working with one of the great orchestras of the world, Herbert von Karajan built the BPO into a successful but tightly controlled group prepared to succeed in any environment. Rattle has deconstructed this model and rebuilt it in a different fashion. Every member played as if they were in a chamber music group. The violins swayed with abandonment that couldn’t be imagined in von Karajan’s day. Conducting the entire work without a score, including the recently completed fourth movement, Rattle made gestures here and there but never imposed himself on the instrumentalists.

It seems only fair to suspend critical judgment on the US premiere of the reconstructed fourth movement. Started in 1983, first performed in 1991 but still considered a work in progress until 2010, this finale deserves to be heard several more times before it’s reviewed. Unquestionably, it has the Bruckner signature sound, the grand crescendos, the prominence of the brass. Whether it matches Bruckner’s other final movements and creates a conclusion that feels right remains a question. This premiere has generated much excitement and expectation, so mentioning the opinion of a detractor might add some balance. This is particularly important as it comes from one of the great Bruckner conductors, George Tintner: “It is not meant cruelly when I say that I for one am glad that Fate did not grant him his wish [to complete the symphony before he died]…for the Finale is unworthy of what is perhaps Bruckner’s greatest music… The various efforts of brilliant scholars who have recently made performing version of Bruckner’s Finale will be of entirely historical interest.”

Frequently today part of a music critic’s comments focus on how rude the audiences are. The sold-out audience for this concert was exemplary: barely a rustle, cough or “ahem.” It was ninety minutes of Bruckner, and the reception bodes well: the time may have finally arrived to place him on a pedestal next to Mahler.

Stan Metzger

Print Friendly

Comments

Comments are closed.

Recent Reviews

Facebook-button-1

Season Previews

__________________________________
  • NEW! Visiting Orchestras Tour Switzerland 2016/2017 __________________________________
  • NEW! Mirga Gražinytė-Tyla’s First Season with the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra Announced __________________________________
  • NEW! Bayreuth Festival 2016 Rings The Changes __________________________________
  • NEW! Dance at The Music Center: 2016-2017 Los Angeles Season __________________________________
  • NEW! Sadler’s Wells Autumn/Winter Season 2016 __________________________________
  • NEW! ENO’s 2016/17 Season At A Glance __________________________________
  • NEW! Tonhalle Orchestra Zurich announces details of new season 2016/2017 __________________________________
  • NEW! Bregenz Festival 2016: a preview __________________________________
  • NEW! Osipova Leaps into a New Programme of Contemporary Dance at Sadler’s Wells in June __________________________________
  • NEW! The Wiener Staatsoper Unveils its Programme for the 2016/2017 Season __________________________________
  • NEW! The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, Announces its 2016/17 Season __________________________________
  • Subscribe to Review Summary Newsletter

    Reviews by Reviewer

    News and Featured Articles

    __________________________________
  • NEW! NCEM Announces Winners of Its Young Composers Award 2016 __________________________________
  • NEW! Brook Street Band Celebrates 20th Anniversary __________________________________
  • R.I.P. IN MEMORIAM – STAN METZGER (1947 – 2016) __________________________________
  • NEW! Do I Repeat Myself? Very Well – I Repeat Myself __________________________________
  • NEW! When Boris isn’t Godunov – by Jack Buckley __________________________________
  • NEW! John Cranko’s Genius Remembered in Three Part Tribute __________________________________
  • NEW! Another Major Singing Competition at RNCM Discovers Names to Look Out For __________________________________
  • NEW! The Pursuit of Discovery: An Interview with Conductor John Storgårds __________________________________
  • NEW! London Brass and O Duo at Wigmore Hall – The 2016 Annual Jacqueline du Pré Charity Concert __________________________________
  • Archives by Week

    Archives by Month

    Search S&H