Jonas Kaufmann is Not Yet Back to his Best Form in Wagner, But Pappano is


Wagner, The Jonas Kaufmann Residency: Jonas Kaufmann (tenor), Karita Mattila (soprano), Eric Halfvarson (bass), London Symphony Orchestra / Sir Antonio Pappano (conductor). Barbican Hall, London. 8.2.2017. (JPr)

Jonas Kaufmann sings Wagner, with the London Symphony Orchestra conducted by Sir Antonio Pappano, as part of 'The Kaufmann Residency' in the Barbican Hall on Wednesday, 8 February 2017. Photo by Mark Allan

Jonas Kaufmann, London Symphony Orchestra & Sir Antonio Pappano (conductor) (c) Mark Allan

Wagner – Prelude to Tristan und IsoldeWesendonck LiederDie Walküre (Act I)

Having the night before seen the supposed ‘star’ of the evening somewhat outshone by those around her (Angela Gheorghiu in Adriana Lecouvreur) I arrived at The Kaufmann Residency and will end up suggesting the success of the evening was because of Antonio Pappano, the London Symphony Orchestra and the contributions of Karita Mattila and Eric Halfvarson rather than the ‘main man’ himself, Jonas Kaufmann.

When I first heard Pappano conduct Lohengrin at Bayreuth in 1999 I thought he would become one of the great Wagner conductors, but unfortunately his performances of that composer’s music during his long tenure at Covent Garden have paled in comparison to some of his other work there. Tonight, however, from the opening of the Prelude to Tristan und Isolde in this all-Wagner programme to the exhilarating conclusion to Act I of Die Walküre, he confounded my expectations. There was much to admire in the lyrical, romantic warmth Pappano achieved from the splendid LSO. He marshalled his forces with a wonderful awareness of Wagner’s finely-wrought structures of scoring and motivic figurations. He was clearly acutely mindful of his tenor’s current vocal abilities, though mostly he never exploited dynamic contrast simply for easy effect. Under Pappano the volume of the orchestral peaks were purely an organic manifestation of the yearning and sexual passion inherent in much of Wagner’s music.

Some of those phrases – which once heard are never forgotten – are there in the Prelude to Tristan und Isolde, along with the composer’s concept of ‘endless melodies’ and his supposed heralding in of ‘modern music’ through the opening ‘Tristan’ chord. This slowly unwinding music was given a rendition that was refined, dramatically paced and dynamically fluid.

Jonas Kaufmann is continuing his return to singing after his well-advertised hiatus. He came back as Lohengrin in Paris (review here), but here made the serious misstep of attempting the Wesendonck Lieder so soon after his recovery. I reviewed his CD release (review here) and although I have heard him in the opera house on numerous occasions, this was the first time I have heard him in a concert since Edinburgh in 2006! These songs were originally published as ‘Five Poems for a Female Voice’; though perhaps there is no real reason a man cannot explore how suffering is intrinsic to life, angels, a hothouse or the dream-world of lovers. Indeed, Lauritz Melchior apparently recorded some of them.

With close links between two of the songs and Tristan und Isolde, the Wesendonck Lieder are strictly not so much Wagner as the work of Felix Mottl’s orchestrations of earlier piano or chamber versions. It would be interesting to hear from anyone at the back of the Barbican Hall balcony how much they heard of Kaufmann’s performance. At the present stage of his convalescence from his vocal cord trauma Kaufmann’s voice seems somewhat diminished; there is a sense of fragility in the highest floated top notes and he use his full-throated tone sparingly. His rendition had an intimacy that would have been better suited to the Wigmore Hall and with piano accompaniment. Wagnerian phrases seemed unduly short-changed, nevertheless ‘Schmerzen’ (Sorrows) was restless and impassioned and ‘Träume’ created a suitably dreamy atmosphere. There was an overreliance on soft head voice and – to be truthful – I have often heard some baritones sing in recital higher than Kaufmann was during these songs. More importantly, there is a sense of existentialism that listeners need to experience from great performances of this cycle: despite the valiant support of Pappano and the LSO, Kaufmann never approached the ‘out of body’ transcendence necessary.

After the interval everything was raised to another level. The first act of Die Walküre must be among the most oft-performed concert excisions from Wagner’s Ring. Pappano whipped up a storm right from the start and – perfectly paced at 67 minutes – conductor and orchestra settled to an urgent – though sublimely lyrical – reading capped by an incandescent account of the sensual love scene that brought the Barbican Hall audience to their feet. Sadly Jonas Kaufmann was a rather lightweight Siegmund. Admittedly, his burnished timbre and unforced lyricism was impeccable, but whilst his visceral cries of ‘Wälse!’ were brilliant, his ‘Winterstürme’ – which though admirably caressing and tender – had just too many crooning soft moments. He currently does not have the complete range of dynamics or projection to ride orchestral climaxes as a Wagnerian heroic tenor should. On the plus side, his diction was – as to be expected – quite unimpeachable.

The declamatory Karita Mattila is not a ‘natural’ Sieglinde yet was utterly compelling. Throughout she was neurotic-sounding and by the end of the act she sounded utterly unbalanced and on the verge of insanity. (For some reason she conjured up for me the memory of Gloria Swanson’s performance in Billy Wilder’s Sunset Boulevard film.) It was Eric Halfvarson who nearly stole the vocal honours from her with a superbly characterised Hunding. There was no mask of politeness here from his deep, baleful and sonorous bass voice, he was just a big bully harbouring possessive resentment.

Jim Pritchard 

For more about events at the Barbican visit .

Click here for Robert Beattie’s review of 4 February recital in The Kaufmann Residency.

Print Friendly


Leave a Reply

Recent Reviews


Season Previews

  • NEW! 2017 BBC Proms from Friday 14 July – Saturday 9 September __________________________________
  • NEW! Tonhalle Orchestra Zurich Announces Details of New Season 2017/2018 __________________________________
  • NEW! Grange Park Opera’s 2017 Season in its New Opera House __________________________________
  • NEW! The Royal Opera House Announces its 2017/18 Season __________________________________
  • NEW! In 2017 The Three Choirs Festival is from 22 to 29 July __________________________________
  • NEW! Glyndebourne Festival 2017: At Glyndebourne, At the Cinema and On Tour __________________________________
  • NEW! The Cleveland Orchestra in 2017-18 __________________________________
  • NEW! Bampton Classical Opera in 2017 features Salieri’s The School of Jealousy __________________________________
  • NEW! Leeds Lieder Announces Seventh Festival of Song for April __________________________________
  • NEW! Zurich Opera Announces its 2017/2018 Season __________________________________
  • NEW! English National Ballet’s 2017 – 2018 Autumn/Winter Season __________________________________
  • NEW! General Booking is Now Open for Longborough Festival Opera 2017 __________________________________
  • NEW! 2017 Lucerne Summer Festival __________________________________
  • NEW! Classical Music at London’s Southbank Centre in 2017-18 __________________________________
  • Subscribe to Review Summary Newsletter

    Reviews by Reviewer

    News and Featured Articles

  • NEW! IN MEMORIAM LOUIS FRÉMAUX (1921-2017) __________________________________
  • NEW! Robert Farr reports on the 26th Annual Singing Competition Final – Elizabeth Harwood Memorial Award for Singers __________________________________
  • UPDATED IN MEMORIAM NICOLAI GEDDA (1925-2017) __________________________________
  • NEW! HOW TO CONTACT SEEN AND HEARD INTERNATIONAL __________________________________
  • NEW! Reviews of Opera in Mumbai: A Gala and La Bohème Revisited __________________________________
  • NEW! FIVE YOUNG SINGERS JOIN THE JETTE PARKER YOUNG ARTISTS FOR 2017 __________________________________
  • NEW! REVIEWERS OF SEEN AND HEARD INTERNATIONAL PICK THEIR BEST OF 2016 __________________________________
  • NEW! The Mastersingers Celebrate Wagner Past and Present with the Rehearsal Orchestra __________________________________
  • Archives by Week

    Archives by Month

    Search S&H