Opera Danube Brings The Waltz-King to St. John’s Smith Sqaure

October 20, 2014

United KingdomUnited Kingdom  Opera Danube Present Johann Strauss II’s Die Fledermaus (a semi-staged concert version directed by Simon Butteriss): soloists, The London Oriana Choir, Orpheus Sinfonia, Oliver Gooch (conductor). St. John’s, Smith Square, London, 18.10.2014. (JPr)


Die Fledermaus Photo Credit

Read more

BRB Takes Its War Memories to London

October 19, 2014

United KingdomUnited Kingdom  Ravel, Bliss, Arnold, Britten, Shadows of War: Birmingham Royal Ballet, Royal Ballet Sinfonia,  Paul Murphy (conductor), Sadler’s Wells, London, 17.10.2014 (J.O’D) Read more

Revival of Blood Brothers Lives Up to Expectations

October 19, 2014

United KingdomUnited Kingdom. Willy Russell: Blood Brothers: Birmingham Hippodrome, 14.10.2014 (GR).


Maureen Nolan as Mrs Johnstone   Sean Jones as Mickey - "Blood Brothers" Photo (c) Birmingham Hippodrome

Maureen Nolan as Mrs Johnstone Sean Jones as Mickey – “Blood Brothers” Photo (c) Birmingham Hippodrome

Read more

Committed Dancing in Richly Textured Manon

October 18, 2014

United KingdomUnited Kingdom Massanet, Manon: Soloists, Royal Ballet, Orchestra of Royal Opera House Orchestra / Martin Yates. (conductor). Directed for the screen by Ross MacGibbon and broadcast to the Ham Yard Hotel, Soho, London. 16.10.2014. (JPr)


Manon photo (c) Mikhail Logvinov

Manon photo (c) Mikhail Logvinov


Manon: Marianela Nuñez
Les Grieux: Federico Bonelli
Lescaut: Ricardo Cervera
Monsieur G.M.: Christopher Saunders
Lescaut’s Mistress: Laura Morera
Madame: Elizabeth McGorian
Gaoler: Gary Avis
Beggar Chief: James Hay

Choreography: Kenneth MacMillan
Orchestration: Martin Yates
Designs: Nicholas Georgiadis
Lighting design: John B. Read

I must start with the best moment from the backstage films that accompanied this live relay of Manon and that was when Lady Deborah MacMillan, the choreographer’s widow, was recalling how she was often asked who her favourite Manon was, and she got so fed up she answered as a joke that the movement was ‘all worked out on me at home in the nude’ … and it was published! More significant was how Sir Kenneth’s obsession with ice skating was the inspiration behind all the swirling pas de deux; Darcey Bussell – herself a fine Manon but clearly awe-struck discussing the role with Lady MacMillan – concurred that she had ‘literally to glide along the floor in every slide and every lift.’ (A full version of this fascinating interview is apparently available for download on the ROH website in their Manon Digital Programme.)

This story of Manon originated in a 1731 novel by Abbé Prévost; she is a young woman who cannot decide between the genuine love of the penniless Des Grieux or the luxury offered by a rich roué Monsieur G.M. whom she doesn’t love. The setting is eighteenth-century Paris where it seems people were either rich and powerful, taking a keen interest in the lives of the demi-monde, or poor and destitute where criminality or prostitution were their only escape routes. As Jann Parry’s programme note explained: ‘The ballet’s setting, lavish though it appears, exposes these contrasts. Behind each change of scene hangs a background of rags; urchins scrabble for coins as women parade their finery, acquired in exchange for sexual services. Everyone has a price.’ Manon seems to be on a loser whichever option she chooses; her choice to eventually flee Paris after a series of unfortunate events – including helping Des Grieux cheat to win money playing cards and then the death of her pimp-like brother Lescaut- has fatal consequences. Weak and emaciated, she will die in the arms of her lover.

This three act narrative ballet begins in the bustling courtyard of an inn near Paris and ends in the murky swamps of Louisiana. Along the way there is everything you would find in a modern soap opera but with infinitely better dancing! There is stealing, illicit love, jealousy, murder, wrongful conviction and sexual abuse. It is the sort of dark story that greatly appealed to Sir Kenneth MacMillan and had a far-from-happy ending that is unusual if compared to many popular fairytale ballets. This version of Manon is celebrating its 40th anniversary and looks rather tame and dated at times now and it is difficult to appreciate – as Jann Parry again recalls – how outrageous it seemed in the 1970s; apparently according to The Guardian ‘Basically, Manon is a slut and Des Grieux is a fool and they move in the most unsavoury company.’

Many ballerinas – including Darcey Bussell obviously – view dancing Manon as a highlight of their career, as the character has to be (as explained elsewhere in the printed programme) ‘an ingénue in Act I, queen of the demi-monde in Act II, or destitute convict in Act III’. Putting it even more simply she must be coy, naively flirtatious, express deep love … and then die convincingly. Most of this Marianela Nuñez seemed to do very well, her acting and dancing was natural and unforced and her fluid arms and the crispness of her leg and footwork shone through all she did. With her chopped hair and ragged clothes, she was barely recognisable as the same woman who luxuriated in being draped in expensive furs and jewels in Act II. Whether revelling in being alone with Des Grieux in his bedroom or having to endure the brutal rape by her prison guard at the Louisiana penal colony – in the most dramatically plausible scene of the entire ballet with Gary Avis’s lascivious Gaoler – Nuñez’s interpretation was compelling and I could not take my eyes off her. This of course was help by the close-ups allowed for in the cinema relay by Ross MacGibbon’s camera direction. Unfortunately Marianela Nuñez never convinced me that she was ever on her way to a convent – as she is supposed to be in Act I – and oozed sex until she finally succumbs in Act III.

The Royal Ballet seem to have a surfeit of leading female dancers at the moment but the men that I get to see in these live cinema broadcasts are not always so strong. Here Federico Bonelli – fine technical dancer as he seems – was not a great actor and had one facial expression all evening right up until he wailed over Manon’s death in his arms as the curtains closed the final time. He looked the same whether it was the euphoric love duets or his reflective solo moments. For me there was a lack of real passion in the famous Act I bedroom scene and they seemed just like a brother and sister mucking around. Ricardo Cervera was better as Manon’s conniving brother Lescaut who is willing to make a profit from his sister’s virtue. This thoroughly despicable character is given a cleverly choreographed drunk scene in Act II – that seems to come from an entirely different ballet – as he tries to partner Laura Morera who was excellent as his mistress. Every step Lescaut takes is off balance, but Cervera – as a more than capable dramatic dancer – expertly timed each step. He is also later given a swordfight that seems to have been lifted from Kenneth MacMillan’s earlier Romeo and Juliet.

Christopher Saunders was the aristocrat Monsieur G. M. and his haughty bearing left no doubt that he was used to getting whatever he wanted. When he was with Manon – the woman he desired and cynically bought – he lost control and could hardly keep hands off her and his pawings and foot fetishism was suitably distasteful. Elizabeth McGorian also stood out in the smaller roles as a suitably elegant, yet unscrupulous, Madame.

Manon’s choreography ranges from complicated lower body work, as well as, some extravagant lifts to the rolling, dropping to floor and leaping choreography of the townspeople and beggars, with a number of those slides and glides (as Darcey Bussell called them) for both the principals and the corps de ballet. Throughout Kenneth MacMillan conflates a variety of ballet styles and incorporates trios as well as duets and solo work. For me the destitution, depravity and passion was all just a little sanitised for 2014. Whether this has been diluted through endless revivals I cannot be sure as I have not seen the full ballet since the 1980s. Nevertheless Manon remains a richly textured ballet, with those dancers around the fringes of the stage being almost as important as the principals in creating a proper background for the central tale of the two doomed lovers. The company seem in good shape, no one appeared to switch off and all danced with admirable commitment.

However, a major weakness is the score and although the ballet is set to music by Massenet – originally arranged by Leighton Lucas in collaboration with Hilda Gaunt and now re-orchestrated by Martin Yates who conducted this performance – it does not include a note from Massenet’s opera of the same name. In the hindsight of 40 years a commissioned score might have strengthened the production. Undoubtedly Massenet did write some lovely melodies, and whilst the arrangers shrewdly incorporated one of his best-known tunes, the lovely and reflective Élégie into each of the three acts, it remains a strangely Classic FM-like musical potpourri. Act II sounds much too Spanish and Act III cranks up the romantic ecstasy when something much more poignant would be better. The Orchestra of the Royal Opera House sounded great even if it was all a little too loud in the auditorium I was sitting in.

This neatly brings me to Ham Yard Hotel that was hosting the ROH’s launch of its 2014/15 Live Cinema Season courtesy of its owners Tim and Kit Kemp. It is all mightily impressive though it is situated in an up-an-coming – but still rather grotty – part of Soho where every venue or eatery appears to have at least two imposing bouncers on its doors. Perhaps they describe this part of London to their clientele as East Mayfair! It boasts a 176 seat ‘state-of-the-art’ theatre and the tangerine orange leather seats were very striking and comfortable. Disturbingly there were glitches in the projection during Act I that spoilt my enjoyment and I hope this was local and not worldwide. Later when this had been resolved sound and vision was fine but no better than at my local cinemas in Basildon and Chelmsford that have similar best-there-is technology.

One of the important innovations this year is that ROH Live Cinema is introducing ‘Encore Screenings’ on the following Sunday of the 11 opera and ballets being relayed live across the UK and the world allowing anyone who cannot get there on the night a second opportunity to see the show.

Jim Pritchard


To view the full list of productions for the 2014/15 season and to find a cinema near you visit http://www.roh.org.uk/cinemas .



NEW!  The Sound World of Opera Director Barrie Kosky

October 18, 2014

 The Sound World of Opera Director Barrie Kosky, Los Angeles16.10.2014 (JRo)


Director Barrie Kosky


Ebullient, outspoken, and intelligent, Barrie Kosky, artistic director of the Komische Oper Berlin and stage director of LA Opera’s upcoming double bill, Dido and Aeneas/Bluebeard’s Castle, presented his concept of this unusual pairing during a conversation with opera president Christopher Koelsch at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion. This is the first in a series of live streaming conversations on the LA Opera’s website – a welcome addition to the Opera’s continuing efforts to offer insights into their productions as they do with their regular pre-performance talks.

 If you were lucky enough to see the LA Opera’s production of The Magic Flute in November 2013, you know that Kosky, along with collaborators Suzanne Andrade and Paul Barritt, were the team responsible for this clever and visually arresting reimagining of the work. If Kosky brings the same level of ingenuity to Dido and Aeneas/Bluebeard’s Castle, then the audience is in for a remarkable evening.

 Conductor Constantinos Carydis conceived of the unconventional pairing of the two operas. Although Kosky acknowledged that the operas, written more than two hundred years apart, are from two entirely different sound worlds, they have narrative parallels and psychological truths in common. Both deal with obsessive love, loneliness, loss, and, on a spiritual and intellectual level, the theme of arrival and departure. Aeneas arrives in Carthage and gains Dido’s love, only to leave again, unknowingly destroying the woman he loves and the empire she rules. Judith arrives at Bluebeard’s Castle, only to find herself trapped in a nightmare world of secrets and unable to leave.


Scene from 2010 Frankfurt Production of Bluebeard’s Castle. Photo (c) Monika Ritterhaus

 Favoring Minimalist stagings to allow the emotional power of the music and the performances to provide maximum heft, Kosky, in one of his many moments of humor, called himself an “Opulent Minimalist.”  His production of The Magic Flute gave the audience a very crowded visual field, but the structures supporting the video projections were simple. For him (and certainly visual artists would agree), Minimalism entails distilling things to their essence.

 In Kosky’s staging, the essence of Bluebeard is not the architecture of the doors and walls in Bluebeard’s castle, but the primacy of the performer and the human voice. In the narrative, Judith’s curiosity compels her to open door after door, looking for a way to let light into the dark enchanted world of the castle. In this new production, set on a slowly revolving white circle, the doors and walls are replaced by bodies harboring those secrets, in a very clever and compelling piece of staging.  Emotions are raw and exposed – a veritable Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf in Hungarian, as Kosky explained to his amused audience.

 In Dido and Aeneas, fragility seems to be the essence of the unfolding tragedy for Kosky: the fragility of Purcell’s score, the fragility of life, and the condition in which Dido finds herself, trapped between the needs of her court and her love for Aeneas. Kosky jokingly urged everyone to bring a box of tissues to cope with the raw power and emotional catharsis of Dido’s final aria and ensuing death.

It is this raw power that interests the director, who asserted that opera as an art form should take the audience out of its emotional comfort zone. Opera “fundamentalists,” as he called those who insist on productions that hark back to their originals, miss the point.  Opera isn’t a fixed form with only one viable approach, but rather, like all theatre, an interpretive art form always open to investigation.

 As for his working methods, he stated that it all starts with choosing the right piece of musical theatre, then “riding the surfboard on the wave” of the music. After assembling a first-rate cast anything becomes possible, because he trusts great performers to draw out character and present human truths. A director with a musical education, Kosky first plays through the score on the piano to digest the music, then listens to as many CDs as he can. Ideas emerge from the process. The rehearsal period is a long one as he and the conductor grapple with how sound should convey the meaning of the libretto’s words. One of the joys of his profession, he said, is directing the chorus. Rather than treating them as a static entity, he prefers to move them into the action to create a deeper level of performance.

 In conclusion, Christopher Koelsch asked Kosky how he sees the future of opera. The director feels that every hurdle is unique to each opera house and its city. But the fundamental issue is accessibility. It’s all about the ticket prices, he explained. Because opera is subsidized in Germany, the lowest ticket price at the Komische Oper is eight euros. Subsidies allow Kosky to reach a broad audience and at the same time maximize the productions with full orchestra, full chorus, and top performers. In his view, opera is here to stay. It’s the only theatrical form that links us to the ancient Greeks – to Euripides, Aeschylus, and Sophocles – and because of that we are linked to something primal…and, one hopes, eternal.


Jane Rosenberg 

Virginia Woolf Inspires De-Edwardianised Dance Drama

October 18, 2014

United KingdomUnited Kingdom  Like Rabbits:  Lost Dog and Lucy Kirkwood, The Place, London, 10.10.2014 (J.O’D)

Ben Duke and Lucy Kirkwood - Like Rabbits (photo by Benedict Johnson)

Ben Duke and Lucy Kirkwood – Like Rabbits (photo by Benedict Johnson)

Read more

Élan and Conviction in BRB’s  Beauty and the Beast

October 17, 2014

United KingdomUnited Kingdom Glenn Buhr, Beauty and the Beast: Dancers of Birmingham Royal Ballet and Royal Ballet Sinfonia / Philip Ellis. Sadler’s Wells, London, 14.10.2014. (JPr)

Beauty and the Beast  Photo Birmingham Royal Ballet

Beauty and the Beast (Photo Birmingham Royal Ballet)

Read more

Stimulating and Thought-Provoking Don Giovanni from NZ Opera

October 16, 2014

New ZealandNew Zealand Mozart, Don Giovanni: The New Zealand Opera, Chapman Tripp Opera Chorus (Chorus Master: Michael Vinten), Orchestra Wellington  / Wyn Davies (conductor), St James’ Theatre, Wellington, 11th, 14th, 16th, 18th October, 2014 Read more

Next Page »

Recent Reviews

Join our Email List!


Click Images Below for 2014 Reviews



Season Previews

Top 10 Reviewed Cities




News and Featured Articles

Monthly Archive

Search Reviews After April 2011