Manon Lescaut Disappoints


GermanyGermany Puccini: Manon Lescaut, Staatskapelle and Staatsoper Dresden, Pier Giorgio Morandi (conductor), Semperoper Dresden 18.6.2013 (JMI).

Production: Graz Opernhaus and Semperoper Dresden

Direction: Stefan Herheim
Sets: Heike Scheele
Costumes: Gesine Völlm
Lighting: Fabio Antoci

Manon Lescaut: Norma Fantini
Des Grieux: Thiago Arancam
Lescaut: Markus Butter
Geronte: Maurizio Muraro


Manon_02 (2)-1

© Matthias Creutziger

My visit to Dresden came to an end in a rather disappointing way. The truth is that this performance of Manon Lescaut can be summarized in one word: boring. Puccini without emotion is unbearable.

The production bears the signature of Norwegian Stefan Herheim. He boasts a legion of fans who seem to compete among themselves in their praise for their idol. I do not always share the admiration for this director since I believe that his duty should be to narrate the story in an understandable manner. And if it is not easily understood, the blame should fall on the director, not on the opera goer.

One of the reasons for the failure of this performance is precisely the Herheim production: by offering his own interpretation he removes any hint of emotion. A central theme of the opera is the protagonists’ desire for liberty, a wish represented here by the Statue of Liberty which could be visited in Paris before France donated it to the United States in 1886. The start of the opera takes place, therefore, in the workshop where the Statue of Liberty is being built. Des Grieux appears to be its sculptor, and there are many visitors to the workshop, including Manon. The story that Herheim tells has little to do with Abbé Prévost’s or Puccini’s: here America represents a dream of freedom for Manon and des Grieux, but in the novel and in the opera the couple are deported by boat to Louisiana. They don’t go on a kind of pleasure cruise, as Herheim would have it. He also adds one more character to the plot: none other than Giacomo Puccini himself. Puccini directs the singers and lets them know which changes he has introduced in Prévost’s novel, a book that is almost continuously in the hands of the singers, who seem to be reading it when singing. The problem is that Puccini gets involved in the action, and thus Manon does not sing the aria Sola, perduta, abandonata to herselfbut to Puccini in his office. She dies finally not in des Grieux’s arms but in Puccini’s. Where? It’s supposed to be America, but there is no trace of the Louisiana “desert.” Emotion is never present here because everything is just pure playacting with Puccini as director.

To complicate matters Herheim creates a kind of puzzle with the costumes. In Act I the workers are dressed in 19th-century costumes, while visitors wear a mix of clothes from the 18th and 19th centuries. Des Grieux wears an 18th-century coat in Act 2, and ends up fully clothed in pre-French Revolution garb in Act 3. The lovers show up in America in different clothes. Who knows where in the desert they bought them.

I have enjoyed other Herheim productions, but not this one. I think the first obligation of any director should be to serve the opera. Here Herheim does not serve it, he just makes use of it.

Daniel Oren was announced as conductor, but he canceled and was replaced by Pier Giorgio Morandi, whose conducting was flat, superficial and routine. No objection can be made to the Staatskapelle Dresden, which was definitely the best element in the performance.

Manon Lescaut was sung by Norma Fantini, whose performance was short on excitement but with the notes in place. She is a solid soprano although I have never been truly moved by her singing.

Brazilian tenor Thiago Arancam made a poor des Grieux. His voice is rather artificial, with an ingolato sound both in the middle and at the bottom of the tessitura. His voice projected poorly and was continuously covered by the orchestra; the high notes were pushed and with dubious pitch. As an actor he simply overdoes it.

Markus Butter as Lescaut had a small voice that projected poorly. Maurizio Muraro was good as Geronte (at least we could hear him).

Semperoper was at about 95% of capacity. The audience was rather cold; I did not hear any cheers at the final bows, but rather some booing for Thiago Arancam.

Jose Mª. Irurzun



Comments are closed.

Recent Reviews

Season Previews

  • UPDATED ONLINE NEWS! IMPACT OF CORONAVIRUS (COVID-19) PANDEMIC __________________________________
  • NEW! BBC Proms turns 125 years old – 17 July to 12 September 2020 __________________________________
  • NEW! Opera North in 2020-2021 – postponements and plans __________________________________
  • NEW! Tonhalle Orchestra Zurich 2020-2021 __________________________________
  • UPDATED! Glyndebourne Festival Opera opens for a 2020 summer season __________________________________
  • NEW! Baritone Federico Longhi’s Rigoletto is part of Parma’s June Verdian renaissance __________________________________
  • NEW! 69th Wexford Festival Opera – 11 to 18 October 2020 __________________________________
  • NEW! Dresden’s Semperoper reopens with Anna Netrebko on 19 June __________________________________
  • NEW! Berlin’s Pierre Boulez Saal in 2020-21 __________________________________
  • NEW! LMP’s first UK chamber orchestra performances since Covid-19 struck __________________________________
  • NEW! Oxford Lieder Festival – 10-17 October 2020 __________________________________
  • NEW! The Metropolitan Opera (2020–)2021 season update __________________________________
  • NEW! Royal Opera House announces first live concert since beginning of lockdown __________________________________
  • NEW! Semi-staged Das Rheingold on Deutsche Oper Berlin’s parking deck from 12 June __________________________________
  • NEW! A breath of fresh air: Opera Holland Park announces 2021 season __________________________________
  • NEW! Grange Park Opera’s 2020 Found Season – 4 June to 12 July __________________________________
  • UPDATED! 2020 Salzburg Festival – 1 to 30 August __________________________________
  • NEW! English Music Festival’s 2020 online series of concerts and talks __________________________________
  • The Singapore Symphony in 2020-2021 __________________________________
  • Subscribe to Free Review Summary Newsletter

    Search S&H

    News and Featured Articles

  • NEW! We’ll be back! The City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra weathering the Covid-19 storm __________________________________
  • NEW! World Ballet School Day – inaugural edition 7 July 2020 __________________________________
  • UPDATED! Longborough Festival Opera launches podcast and extraordinary generosity of the audience __________________________________
  • NEW! The Music Critics Association of North America Best New Opera Award to Blue __________________________________
  • NEW! Lincoln Center honors Pride with a light installation on its iconic plaza __________________________________
  • R.I.P. Dame Vera Lynn (1917-2020): Did we really need Vera Lynn during the war? __________________________________
  • NEW! What price Sherlock Holmes? __________________________________
  • NEW! BBC to show the ROH’s first post-lockdown performance and their other recent music news __________________________________
  • NEW! Woody Allen comes back fighting with a book and A Rainy Day in New York __________________________________
  • NEW! Educating Rita, says who? __________________________________
  • NEW! 2020 Three Choirs Festival – postponed __________________________________
  • NEW! Need to escape reality? Enter into the magical world of composer David Hertzberg __________________________________
  • NEW! BTHVN2020 – Beethoven anniversary goes into overtime __________________________________
  • Archives by Week

    Archives by Month